Just when it looked like the smoke had cleared, a controversial debate over wood-burning fire rings has returned to the City of Newport Beach.
In a 5-2 vote Tuesday, members of the Newport Beach City Council voted to allow wood-burning fire rings at beaches in Balboa and Corona del Mar. The move reverses an earlier decision to remove all the rings and convert them to charcoal-only.
"Charcoal doesn't keep you warm," said Council Member Scott Peotter. "It's great for cooking hamburgers, but when it comes to a bonfire, it just doesn't cut it."
Under an immediate interim plan, 15 to 30 wood-burning rings will be returned. The council also approved a permanent proposal, however, which will see the reinstatement of all 60 wood-burning fire rings. That plan still needs a green light from the California Coastal Commission. By spacing the rings further apart, the council believes it can still comply with South Coast Air Quality Management District regulations.
Council Members Keith Curry and Diane Dixon voted against the plan Tuesday, citing the health concerns.
“I just think anyone who denies the health impacts, particularly given the testimony … should be ashamed of themselves,” Curry said.
Read more about Tuesday’s vote here.